It think this is a good representation of character because even though they are fighting, you can get a sense of how they act when they aren't. This individul scene wraps up their essence well because this is a tragedy and they are the type of people who can joke about it. Also, this demonstrates relational conflict because they are breaking up and there is nothing Marshall can do to change Lily's mind. This is just something she has to do. Lastly, I think the dialogue fits the characters extremely well in this scene.
Friday, April 11, 2014
How I Met Your Mother: Character
This scene of How I Met Your Mother is a collection of different moments in the episode where Marshall and Lily break up. They have been together since the first day of college, nine years, and are about to get married, but Lily has cold feet. She is a painter and a kindergarden teacher who had dreams of traveling the world. Marshall is getting his degree to be an environmental lawyer. Another thing you need to know about this scene is that when Lily and Marshall fight, they tend to last days, so, they decided at any time during an arguement they could say pause to stop the fighting. That's why they weren't yelling at eachother while they were talking about pudding and Ted. He is their roomate and the one who found Marshall sitting on the steps at the end.
I enjoyed your post, I think that this scene represents Lily and Marshall very well. I liked that in the scene how they weren't yelling so, you could tell that Lily and Marshall aren't angry people. I also liked how this showed the relational conflict. Good job!
ReplyDeleteOf course, since this is a HIMYM post, I feel obligated to comment on it; and, to add to it, you chose a fantastic scene which I agree shows strong character development between Marshall and Lily, both as individuals and in terms of their relationship conflict. What makes this scene truly heartbreaking, in my opinion, is exactly how you pointed out that "there is nothing Marshall can do to change Lily's mind. This is just something she has to do" because Marshall feels completely powerless in this situation. He loves Lily, and she loves him, but sometimes, somebody needs to leave a relationship in order to grow as an individual. Relationship conflicts, as shown in this scene, can be shocking, unexpected, and tragic. Well done. :)
ReplyDeleteI've never seen this show but the way you explained it help me understand it more and it seems like a good show! Nice job explaining the characters and the relationship conflict.
ReplyDelete